Welcome to Sylvan Shores Diner
At Sylvan Shores Diner, nestled along Kelly Street in Rome City, IN, you’ll find a charming blend of nostalgia and comfort. This lake house-inspired eatery embodies the spirit of a classic diner, serving up hearty dishes with a smile. From crispy onion petals to the satisfying Philly steak sandwich, the menu is thoughtfully crafted to delight every palate. Guests rave about the welcoming atmosphere and attentive service, making it a beloved spot for locals and visitors alike. Sylvan Shores Diner isn’t just a place to eat; it’s a gathering spot that celebrates good food and great company.
Sylvan Shores Diner: Reviews & Ratings
Amazing food and service with a neat lake house esthetic. And very affordable prices. About 10 per person
We finally decided to stop in & give them a try. So glad we did! The food was excellent! I had the half biscuits & gravy & half home fries. The potatoes were awesomely browned crispy & full of good old fashioned bacony flavor along with the gravy! Fresh biscuits. The service was awesome & prompt with a kind & beautiful smile. I loved the atmosphere. It seemed like an old fashioned diner, decorated nicely along great service! We will be back to try lunch! Wish we would have tried this place sooner. We are local. Give this place a try!
Me and my kids LOVED eating here! All the staffed had smiles and worked together and were amazing! We always had refills and they were fast on getting food out for being busy. We will definitely be back!
Absolutely a home town diner. Good portions , great staff , and excellent service . Keep up the good work ! I’m excited to have another option for my family. The Beer Battered Cod was great !
I came here the first day they opened. Waited almost 2 hours and never ate lol. They have come a long way since then. Whether you are a local or driving thru town, stop by for good service and excellent breakfast. I personally go at least twice a week
Love this place, it's a little over an hour away and we try to get there once or twice a month. Food is always good, service is fast and friendly. Hopefully they bring the chicken salad wrap back.
This restaurant is so accommodating. Our cycling group dines here when in town. Love the service and the food. Reasonable prices.
Love all the waitresses . Food is delicious . Very accommodating. I will always choose the diner for our weekend breakfast and any other chance I get.
Location
-
611 Kelly St Ext, Rome City, IN 46784, United States Hotline: +1 260-303-1469
Welcome to Sylvan Shores Diner, a delightful culinary gem nestled in the heart of Rome City, Indiana. Located at 611 Kelly St Ext, this charming diner captures the essence of old-fashioned warmth and hospitality, reminiscent of classic American diners. Operating under a cozy lake house aesthetic, this establishment has quickly established itself as a beloved spot for locals and visitors seeking hearty meals and friendly service.
Sylvan Shores Diner offers a mouth-watering selection that will satisfy any appetite. Their famous Smash Butter Burgers are a real treat, with options like the enticing Patty Melt at just $6.50, and the savory Bacon Cheese at $6.25. For the classic burger lover, the Hamburger priced at only $5.25, is a must-try. If you’re in the mood for something unique, don’t miss the The Sylvan at $7.25, which promises a burst of flavors. The menu also features baskets brimming with favorites, including Beer Battered Shrimp ($9.75) and 2 Chili Cheese Dogs ($7.50).
- Delicious Dishes to Highlight:
- Beer Battered Pollock – A local favorite, crispy and flaky, at $9.75
- Fresh Biscuits & Gravy – A comfort food classic, praised for its perfectly crispy potatoes and rich gravy.
Customer reviews reflect the diner’s commitment to quality and service. Derek Harmon describes Sylvan Shores as offering “amazing food and service,” all at “affordable prices.” J Mc shares a delightful experience with their half biscuits & gravy and home fries, noting the “awesome” flavors that accompanied their meal. Brooke Reed, visiting with her children, praised the friendly staff and quick service, making it evident that the diner is a family-friendly destination.
As Gene Landers aptly puts it, Sylvan Shores Diner is “absolutely a hometown diner” where generous portions meet friendly faces. Regulars like Camden Welch-Mitchel are drawn back time and again for the inviting atmosphere and consistently delicious breakfasts.
In conclusion, whether you’re a local or just passing through, Sylvan Shores Diner offers a delightful dining experience that melds comfort, quality, and affordability. With its irresistible menu and welcoming ambiance, it is surely a place you’ll want to visit again and again.
Don’t hesitate to visit or call them at +1 260-303-1469 for more information. Come discover your new favorite diner at Sylvan Shores!